Federalist No. 18

“I wonder further if what we need right now is not a little anarchy in the members of the federal body”

starMadison, in his ongoing effort to convince the public of the merits and virtue of the new federal constitution, makes the connection between the ancient Greek republics and the system of government set up under the Articles of Confederation. In short, those republics were in need of a “closer union.” According to Madison they lacked the uniform connections that are needed to keep disparate and often tumultuous elements together. The danger in having too loose a confederacy of states is that it is ever in want of a great crisis to keep it together. Such was the case when Sparta and Athens united to fight off the invasion of Xerxes in 480 BC. Once the Greek city states were victorious, they “became rivals and then enemies.”

Madison points out that not all Greek republics were utter failures. He approvingly turns towards the Achaean League in the Upper Peloponnese for an illustration of a republic with real merit. What makes this confederation better than its predecessors and in turn more effective than the Articles of Confederation? For starters it was “far more intimate,” meaning it had a more active central authority than other republics before it. Another important distinction was that the cities within the league “retained their municipal jurisdiction, appointed their own officers, and enjoyed a perfect equality.” Furthermore the cities were represented in the senate, which had the power to make war and treaties, to conduct foreign affairs, make alliances and appoint the praetor. So while the cities, according to Madison, shared uniform laws and a national culture, they each retained an important degree of home rule and were represented as cities in the senate.  This important distinction was built into the American federal system with the states having representation in the senate (this feature of the US Constitution has been lost through the 17th Amendment).

Finally, what made the Achaean League so appealing to Madison was the high degree of law, order and liberty that prevailed in the Achaean system of shared power. For Madison, there was no finer example of a workable federal system in all the ancient world. But this ancient example of republican liberty met its demise in the collusion of faction and tyranny. Made weak by internal struggles for preeminence and power by special interests, outside nations overcame the separate city states and eventually the Romans placed chains on the once free republic and brought its federal experiment to an end.

So why does Madison relate the brief history of the antiquated ancient Grecian republics and more particularly the Achaean League? To show the

tendency of federal bodies rather to anarchy among the members than to tyranny in the head.

The lesson of the dangers of special interests to republican liberty is so apparently analogous to our current situation as to warrant no comment but I wonder further if what we need right now is not a little anarchy in the members of the federal body; to wrest the power from concentrated special interests in Washington and spread it out over the capitals of the sovereign states.


3 Responses to Federalist No. 18

  1. Dear Free Algernon:

    I’ve been reading through much of your work here and I like the way you write and think. I also appreciate your tone.

    I’m very patiently and cautiously building a staff that is unique in its viewpoint, and top notch in its scholarship, reasoning skills, and its ability to convey ideas simply, clearly, and persuasively.

    On the other hand I’m not interested in the normal partisan stuff and personality assaults, but a discussion about principles, principles that defend the Judeo-Christian ethic, limited government, and the American Constitution.

    You qualify on every point, and I’d like to formally and enthusiastically invite you to join The Moral Liberal as a member of our staff.

    If you accept you will retain full rights to your material, can co-publish at your free algernon site or anywhere else you please. If you have anything tied to your work that you are marketing you can make mention of it in your byline with live links. We will also run live links from our website to yours in the byline, in our “friends” section.

    There are no minimum contribution rules, you can contribute articles as often as you like on whatever subject you please. If you want to keep the title Free Algernon as your column’s name – which I happen to love — that will work. We’d also like to run a bio in “Our Staff” section. And promote you for talk radio interviews and speaking engagements (if you’d like) in our “Media” section.

    You are free to send over one at a time your previous work, for instance, on the Federalist.

    As our influence grows (this project is only in its sixth or seventh week) I will help facilitate speaking and radio interviews.

    I hope in the next six months to a year to begin the process of a site upgrade (as to design and functionality) and give it a DotCom address.

    A long term goal would include encouraging staff to attend conferences both for educational and networking opportunities as well as eventually holding our own seminars. We have a long way to go but I’m a determined plodder; that’s how I ended up at NewsMax; I expect these goals to be met.

    Please think it over and drop me a line.

    If you have any questions you can contact me either via libertyletters @ gmail.com or at 208 . 852 . 0556

    Afterthought: If because of your school employment you feel you need to keep your public identity secret that is fine. You will just need to reveal it to me and other staff member who would like to know but maintain Free Algernon or whatever for the readers.


    Steve Farrell

  2. Algernon wordmaster teacher man: 🙂

    Please send me your email address, the same what that matches your account with wordpress so that I can give you author privileges at The Moral Liberal.

    Traffic keeps climbing.



  3. Oh yeah, send it to LibertyLetters @ Gmail.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: